Keyhole Pizzeria

Order Now

Delicious Pizzas for Every Craving Today

Discover our delicious featured items today at Keyhole Pizzeria!

Order Now

Alfredo Chicken Bacon

Indulge in our rich Alfredo sauce paired with a delectable three-cheese blend and tender chicken.

Add Item

BBQ All The Meats

Indulge in a mouthwatering mix of BBQ sauce, melted cheddar, rich Monterey Jack.

Add Item

White Pizza

Indulge in the creamy richness of ricotta complemented by a delightful three-cheese blend.

Add Item

Meatballs

Seaven 1-ounce meatballs, topped with marinara sauce and a three-cheese blend.

Add Item

Your Local Pizza Favorite in North Manchester

Since opening in 2024, Keyhole Pizzeria has been serving fresh pizza, pasta, and family favorites in the heart of downtown. Whether you’re craving a classic pepperoni pizza, crispy wings, or a hearty specialty pizza, we’ve got you covered.

Our focus is on fresh ingredients, friendly service, and a cozy dining experience that keeps our customers coming back for more. Conveniently located in the heart of North Manchester, our family-friendly atmosphere makes us the perfect spot for gatherings, celebrations, or a casual night out. Stop by today, order online, or call ahead to enjoy a delicious meal made just for you!

Order Now

Order Pizza, Pasta & More Online Today!

At Keyhole Pizzeria, enjoy flavorful Italian dishes with just a few clicks. Skip the wait and order your favorite pizza and wings online! Our easy-to-use platform lets you customize your meal and schedule pickup or delivery. Serving North Manchester, Laketon, Liberty Mills, Servia, Silver Lake, and Urbana, we bring convenience and great taste right to your table.

Start Your Order

Customer Reviews

Check out our most recent reviews!

Joe Chenery

Really great pizza. Delicious slightly sweet flavor for the crust and sauce had a perfect bite. Generous amount of very fresh tasting cheese and great fresh toppings. With very competitive pricing on a super high quality pizza the keyhole pizzeria is the best around.

Grant Miller

Delicious pizza!..among the very best! I had them use garlic butter in place of tomato-based pizza sauce, the crust was soft with crispy areas, and it was entirely delectable!! The eagerness of both Matt and Martha to make it a delightful pizza, and experience is unsurpassed! Great people, great pizza; what more can ... you ask for?! Read More

Laurie Everitt

We stopped for a late lunch on our way through Indiana, and the pizza was fabulous! Crispy crusts, delicious toppings, and fast and friendly service. What luck for us to stop here!

Jason Bendiksen

Good pizza! The online ordering was easy and we enjoyed our food here. We are just visiting the area, but are glad we got food here.

Luke Gobel

What a perfect dining experience for our team! The owners are wonderful. The pizza is wonderful! I highly recommend. The mushroom pizza was delicious!

Adam Grimme

Pizza was amazing! Highly recommend it!

Eileen Moellers

The food and service were amazing. We got some wings and pizza which were delicious. It’s a great place for families, we plan to come back!

Heather Cruz

Keyhole Pizzeria provided six delicious pizzas for a business luncheon and they were a hit! Martha made the ordering process a breeze, answered all my questions, and the pizzas were enjoyed by all!

Crystalina Alaghwani

Amazing pizza great taste better than Pizza Hut and dominos. Every bite is a mouth full of flavor and deliciousness. The owners are amazing especially Martha great customer service and lovely place to eat in

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of food do you serve?

What are your most popular dishes?

Do you service Downtown North Manchester?

How do you prepare your food?

What are your hours of operation?